| Platinum | Jenny's Cafe | 
| Gold | Stormin' Norman's Shipfaced Saloon | 
| Silver | Dave's Bar and Grill | 
| Bronze | Terry's Breakfast & Lunch | 
| Top Pick | Bearded Ginger | 
| Top Pick | Conley's Place Restaurant | 
| Top Pick | Hangry's | 
| Top Pick | Hello Sugar | 
| Top Pick | IHOP | 
| Top Pick | The Otis Restaurant |