| Platinum | Torra Tea | 
| Gold | Caruso's Sandwiches and Artisan Pizza | 
| Silver | Dave's Bar and Grill | 
| Bronze | Stormin' Norman's Shipfaced Saloon | 
| Top Pick | Bearded Ginger | 
| Top Pick | Black Straw | 
| Top Pick | Crimson Hearth | 
| Top Pick | Little Euro | 
| Top Pick | The Pentagon | 
| Top Pick | Thrifty Scotsman Drive-In |