| Platinum | Caruso's Sandwiches and Artisan Pizza | 
| Gold | Jersey Mike's Subs | 
| Silver | High Nooner | 
| Bronze | Pizza Pipeline | 
| Top Pick | Allie's Vegan Pizzeria & Cafe | 
| Top Pick | Casey's Place | 
| Top Pick | Domini's | 
| Top Pick | Halletts Market & Cafe | 
| Top Pick | Schlotzsky's | 
| Top Pick | Shamus's Sandwich Shop |