| Platinum | Market Street Pizza Valley |
| Gold | Caruso's Sandwiches and Artisan Pizza |
| Silver | Domino's Pizza |
| Bronze | Pizza Pipeline |
| Top Pick | Allie's Vegan Pizzeria & Cafe |
| Top Pick | Fieldhouse |
| Top Pick | River City Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rock City Grill |
| Top Pick | Silverbeard's Marina |
| Top Pick | Versalia |