| Platinum | La Plaza de Mexico |
| Gold | Rancho Viejo |
| Silver | Dos Amigos |
| Bronze | Vaqueros Mexican Restaurant & Taqueria |
| Top Pick | Azteca |
| Top Pick | Casa De Oro |
| Top Pick | Choo Choo Tortas |
| Top Pick | El Sazon |
| Top Pick | Palenque |
| Top Pick | Puebla Family Mexican Restaurant |
| Burrito House |